Contact us anytime to know more — Abhishek P., Founder & CFO CISIN
Be familiar with your organization's rules regarding data storage. While cloud solutions seem. appealing, sometimes leaving infrastructure management up to third parties isn't practical if your business deals with sensitive material like protected health information (PHI).
In such instances, legal restrictions might dictate keeping such records on an on-premise server or private cloud is best.
Open-source Continuous Integration software development has long been driven by its community. Support and plug-ins are readily available online via tutorials.
If your pipeline requires support beyond what a proprietary tool provides or commercial support is available, then an open-source product may also work well; in these instances, commercial support should also be considered an option.
It is better to have multiple CI Tools explicitly tailored to each need than try to squeeze everything into a single solution to protect projects in case one is no longer available or support becomes inadequate.
This approach ensures business continuity when resources for specific CI become unavailable or inadequately supported.
Your ideal Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment tools depend on various considerations such as team size and complexity, existing toolsets, and complexity of projects.
Bamboo's seamless integration with Atlassian products makes it ideal for teams already using that ecosystem; Jenkins provides flexible plug-in support; it's open source and customizable, while GitLab serves organizations looking for DevOps capabilities that combine Continuous Integration/CD with project management abilities.
Your needs and preferences ultimately dictate which tool is the ideal one. At the same time, any of these Continuous Integration/Continuous Delivery Tools will increase development efficiency while increasing code quality - plus promote team collaboration between departments.
Your codebase grows organically as you develop a product; with proper management, it can quickly turn into a Rubik's cube that future developers must unravel to reach a working product version.
Traditional waterfall methodologies such as Waterfall Methodology could take months and sometimes years before shipping an initial version was achieved.
Agile methodologies enabled businesses to reduce programming cycles to weeks and introduce delivery at regular intervals.
Still, continuous integration (CI), or continuous delivery as it is more commonly known nowadays, allows program updates to be released much more rapidly within hours or days - this occurs by developers regularly submitting code into repositories so automated tests can track bugs more effectively before fixing them more rapidly. Our article about Continuous Integration and Delivery will show you its benefits and how best to adopt it in practice.
Want More Information About Our Services? Talk to Our Consultants!
Bamboo
Bamboo from Atlassian is an enterprise tool designed to simplify development pipeline management. Additionally, Bamboo integrates well with Atlassian products like Jira or Bitbucket for improved collaboration in development environments.
Features:
- Integrating Elastic Bamboo into Bitbucket, Jira, or any DevOps tool is effortless.
- Utilize its user-friendly web interface to create build plans and deploy projects and workflows quickly - plus native Docker integration makes containerized deployment and builds seamlessly. Elastic Bamboo provides on-demand building capabilities.
- Build analytics and testing results to provide comprehensive reporting and insight.
Pros:
- Ideal for existing Atlassian users.
- Easy setup and configuration with robust security features.
- Utilizing Bitbucket streamlines development workflow.
Cons:
- Jenkins and GitLab both boast excellent community support.
- Jenkins offers more restricted plug-ins and extensions compared to GitLab.
Jenkins
Jenkins is one of the leading open-source CI/CD toolkits, providing users extensive extensibility options through numerous plug-ins.
It enables the automation of all phases of software development, such as building, testing, and deploying apps.
Features:
- An active community and comprehensive plug-in library enable infinite customization options. At the same time, distributed builds are supported, facilitating concurrent execution on multiple nodes simultaneously.
- Its high scalability makes it ideal for larger-scale projects.
- Integrates seamlessly with various version control systems, including Git, SVN, and Mercurial; adapts to any workflow seamlessly.
Pros:
- By choosing open-source software that's freely available and free to download and use, reducing entry barriers has never been simpler.
- Many third-party plug-ins and tools can be supported through its community-driven solid development platform.
- With regular updates guaranteed through vital community-driven development initiatives, anyone can participate.
Cons:
- Bamboo requires more initial configuration effort than GitLab and extra care when setting up security features.
GitLab
GitLab is a comprehensive DevOps Platform beyond CI/CD models. This includes version control and tracking issues management capabilities and providing an integrated solution to collaborate across the development life cycle.
Features:
- GitLab offers integrated version control (Git), code review, and project management features for software developers and designers.
- GitLab features runners that enable concurrent builds across platforms and environments. At the same time, the Container Registry ensures secure storage and distribution of Docker images.
- Kubernetes integration provides for application deployment in containerized systems.
Pros:
- DevOps is an evolving platform designed to streamline collaboration while simplifying toolchain complexity. At the same time, security testing for containers remains a top priority.
Cons:
- Complex platforms may be overkill for smaller teams seeking a more straightforward CI/CD solution like Jenkins.
- With its tightly managed ecosystem of plug-ins and less extensibility than Jenkins, larger projects might find this too complex and cumbersome of an option to meet their CI/CD needs.
What is a CI/CD Tool, and How Does it Work?
All Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment software performs similar functions: they run repetitive and mundane tasks to deliver iterative code updates to users and cover a diverse selection of functionality.
- The build turns source code into deployable form while test automation automates your testing processes.
- Bring automation to your business.
A continuous integration/continuous delivery (CI/CDl) system comprises two parts: a central CI server, also referred to as "The Master," and one or multiple build agents, which may also be known as build enslaved people or runners or remote agents.
The central server assigns and coordinates jobs and executes them from start to finish, showing their results and tracking execution progress.
It integrates with version control systems to detect changes to source code that trigger pipeline tasks. These platforms support not just integration but continuous delivery.
Build agents are individual remote processes listening to and running tasks on a server, such as GitLab or another famous VCS repository, acting upon commands from its host computer to execute its tasks.
Agents may be set to run tasks automatically on schedule or upon an event such as when new code is added into such repositories as GitHub and GitLab, respectively, where tasks may also be run concurrently by multiple agents for extra efficiency when dealing with large codebases or testing updates across various operating systems; this is how Continuous Integration/CD works so let's explore these options to select one suitable to you and select it correctly.
What To Look For When Choosing A Continuous Integration Tool
There are so many solutions for continuous integration and deployment on the market, so selecting an ideal one can be difficult.
Below are criteria designed to assist in narrowing your options down so you can easily decide.
The Most Praised Features:
As previously discussed, continuous integration/continuous deployment (CI/CD) refers to directly providing code updates from version control systems to users.
Different tools excel in different aspects: some excel at handling integration, while others specialize in testing, debugging, and deployment. Research user specifications and reviews on each solution to better understand its strengths and weaknesses.
Host Options:
Your CI/CD tool may be deployed locally on-premise (your server) or hosted remotely (in the cloud) and must be managed and deployed accordingly by either yourself or a DevOps in-house team.
On-premise tools may provide greater flexibility and security.
Cloud solutions allow end-users access via the Internet. They are fully managed and supported by either their cloud provider (which could also be the same vendor), making this an appealing alternative to traditional software that allows for increased flexibility as it can easily be adjusted on demand.
Compatibility and Integration:
An efficient way to eliminate much of your frustration with new software is ensuring its compatibility with technologies and tools you already use, like continuous integration/continuous deployment tools.
Before choosing one for use on existing technologies. It should work smoothly.
- Operating System (OS)
- Jira Project Management tools and an integrated development environment (IDE).
- Katalon Studio Continuous testing software.
- Version control systems such as Git
- GitLab or Perforce are excellent cloud services to utilize for versioning purposes.
Some CI/CD software is tied to specific VCS providers, virtual machines, or clouds, limiting your deployment and operating system options.
To ensure maximum flexibility, look for platform-independent solutions.
Docker Container Support:
Docker support can be seen in two ways: first, as a tool that facilitates building and deploying Docker containers.
Alternatively, deployment support could mean using Docker containers for deployment purposes - though this latter approach is less prevalent. In the past, continuous integration/continuous deployment (CI/CD) systems were often installed within virtualized computers (VMs).
However, many platforms allow jobs to run directly inside Docker, with several advantages.
- Reusability: Container pipeline blocks can be reused across workflows with Docker as the standard delivery mechanism. Their versatility allows multiple platforms, and their portability doesn't restrict you to just one OS or cloud provider.
Add-Ons and Extensions:
Plug-ins extend functionality by connecting to other environments or technologies, thus broadening your tool's capabilities.
An advantage of free, open-source software solutions in this regard is their user community, which constantly creates extensions that they upload into publicly accessible repositories for upload. Although specific extensions might not be essential to your CI/CD process, they could prove invaluable if used effectively.
Learning Curve and User Interface:
Some tools allow graphical configuration of CI/CD pipelines with clear User interfaces that significantly reduce learning curves, further speeding adoption rates.
Prices and Free Tier:
[The price policy is also important]. Being able to try the product before investing could reduce risk; otherwise, you risk buying into something subpar that costs too much in terms of eroding ROI and creating inefficiency within your organization.
Let's examine some popular Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment tools here].
Jenkins Is The Most Popular CI/CD tool With A Great Community
Jenkins is ideal for projects requiring extensive customization; this may take longer as you need to change everything.
Jenkins is an open-source Java project that runs on Windows, macOS, and Linux as well as in the cloud - it initially provided continuous integration functionality but CI/CD Security Toolsnow covers all aspects of CI/CD - it's free, community-supported software, so it could even become your go-to choice as your first tool.
Selling Points
No expenses are required. Jenkins, a free tool for continuous integration/continuous delivery (CI/CD), can help save you money without incurring expenses.
Jenkins offers unlimited integrations. You can integrate Jenkins with nearly every other program used to develop applications, from Docker or Kubernetes directly out-of-the-box deployment systems like Kubernetes to G2 Crowd Reviewer endorsement, and no other tool compares as effectively when it comes to uniting repositories, code bases, and deployment infrastructure into one powerful solution." G2 Crowd reviewers rave: "No better tool exists today to integrate repositories, code bases, and deployment infrastructure."
Jenkins offers an abundance of plug-ins: Git Gradle Subversion, Jira Redmine Pipeline, Selenium Slack, and Jira Redmine Pipeline Selenium.
Their plug-ins fall under five categories - platform user interface administration, source code management, and build management. Only Jenkins integrates its plug-ins comprehensively; other tools may offer similar features but need this level of integration.
Jenkins encourages its users to expand its functionality through teaching materials creation. Jenkins Community offers guided tours that cover basic and advanced tutorials - called Jenkins World.
Main Weaknesses
Documentation may need to be improved, adding time-consuming tasks for engineers as they must navigate it all themselves.
Wrong User InterfaceThe interface is outdated and doesn't adhere to modern design principles, leaving an overcrowded viewing experience and icons and progress indicators that don't refresh automatically when jobs end. Whitespace is lacking, leaving a cluttered view; many icons and progress indicators appear pixelated; many jobs don't automatically end, leaving customers waiting for jobs to be refreshed by themselves automatically.
Issues with plug-ins Due to being developed by open-source contributors, many plug-ins need adequate support or integration testing, resulting in conflicts among plug-ins developed independently.
Features That Teamcity Has Built-In For Everything
JetBrains' TeamCity provides an impressive CI/CD solution with lots of functionality right out-of-the-box, supporting Docker integration as well as being cross-platform, running on Windows, Linux, and macOS versions as well as Unix variants like Solaris and FreeBSD.
TeamCity can be utilized immediately following installation, providing detailed reports on its history and immediate feedback for failed tests and settings that can be reused to avoid duplicating code.
Pricing Model. TeamCity offers a free 14-day trial for its cloud and on-prem versions but is limited to 100 build configurations with full product access and full build agent access; adding one build agent costs $299 with one configuration each costing $30 extra each time; startups receive 50% discounts; open source projects can license this technology accessible; cloud teams may qualify for monthly licensing from as little as $45 depending on active contributors in their team.
Selling Points
TeamCity is the premier continuous integration (CI) tool for.NET development. Featuring powerful code coverage analysis features and multiple test frameworks, TeamCity stands above competing CI tools supporting .NET programming.
TeamCity supports various environments. It comes with native support for popular tools like Jira (bug tracking), Visual Studio (build automation), Maven, and NuGet; it supports multiple version control systems, including GitHub and GitLab.
TeamCity initially used AWS, but now you can use Microsoft Azure or Google Cloud. Over 400 plug-ins exist to integrate Kubernetes and other services seamlessly with TeamCity's cloud deployments.
TeamCity can be quickly installed and ready for immediate use after being configured. Setup can take less than 5 minutes per server.
TeamCity boasts an abundance of built-in features.
- Build chains and dependencies.
- Source control is a source of information.
- Status monitoring of multiple projects
- Detailed history reports with statistics.
TeamCity displays the status of each build and how many tests remain to pass; you can deploy code into any environment; competent documentation allows users to quickly understand overall functionality by reading its comprehensive user manual.
Main Weaknesses
TeamCity presents a steep learning curve. Although its user interface (UI) may look user-friendly at first glance, newcomers to TeamCity may still need help with its navigation for comfort when first using it in production environments.
Upgrade process manually: Manually upgrading from one version primary to another can take time-consuming steps before the upgrade happens.
Bamboo Data Center Integrates With Atlassian Products Out Of The Box
Atlassian Bamboo is an agile, continuous integration/continuous delivery software platform to streamline delivery.
Compatible with Windows and Linux OSes, Bamboo runs across both environments but will no longer be sold or supported after February 2024; all customers should migrate to Atlassian Cloud before then, as the Bamboo Data Center edition will no longer have support after this date. Existing customers should install new licenses before technical support ends and this deadline.
Bamboo offers flexible pricing models. Trial periods last 30 days before restricting you to only Enterprise-grade Tier features for subscription renewal, such as unlimited software updates and jobs; prices depend upon how many Remote agents or enslaved people are part of your setup - $1200 annually per agent is the starting cost estimate.
Selling Points
Support for Atlassian Products. Bamboo provides native support for other Atlassian products like Bitbucket, Jira, and Confluence through an integration plug-in system for Jenkins.
At the same time, Bamboo Data Center represents an upgrade over its predecessor edition in many respects. Some notable additions are:
- Clustering provides continuous availability and disaster recovery capabilities by quickly replacing failed nodes within your cluster.
- Improved build and delivery resilience means the agent can complete their task even without access to a server and reconnect once finished with their work. Single sign-on support has also become standard across Data Center Products.
- Bamboo on Kubernetes simplifies administrative tasks while increasing agility within your team. Utilization of this Data Center Version has given Bamboo more excellent utility.
Simple deployment. Docker and AWS CodeDeploy provide seamless connections that simplify deployment in development, testing, and production environments.
Atlassian provides documentation and support. Their Bamboo documentation is comprehensive, while their expert services support is second-to-none for Jenkins users - with nearly the whole community still needing to approach that size.
Main Weaknesses
Bamboo supports fewer plug-ins than Jenkins or TeamCity; currently, only 185 applications can be found in the Atlassian Repository.
Bamboo does not currently offer a fully managed cloud version like many similar solutions; thus, your options for running it remain on your servers or cloud resources like AWS (primarily). Bamboo Data Center fits outside the price point for small businesses as each license costs approximately $1200 per agent, thus making its service unsuitable for them.
Read More: Best 15 CI/CD Tools You Must Know 2023
Circleci Is A Mature Platform That Offers A Wide Range Of Integrations
CircleCI is one of the most acclaimed continuous integration and delivery (CI/CD) systems currently in use, serving such clients as Spotify, Coinbase, and Samsung, among many others.
Available as both software-as-a-service offering as well as on hardware or private clouds, it also runs natively on Windows, macOS, Linux Docker as well as all mobile ARM processors found within smartphones, tablets, and wearable devices alike - something no other CI/CD system does currently.
Pricing Models. CircleCI utilizes a pay-as-you-go pricing model. If your monthly build time is at most 6,000 minutes per month, six months are free; after that point, it starts at $15, depending on usage and whether more than five users are involved.
Enterprise plans typically cost at least $2,000 monthly.
Selling Points
CircleCI offers an intuitive dashboard to track your work with real-time analysis and monitoring capabilities, allowing seamless task tracking and management.
CircleCI offers many built-in integrations that are ready-made, such as those for popular tools like GitHub and Bitbucket, as well as version control systems like Redmine.
- Languages and services offered by major cloud service providers (AWS, Google Azure, Microsoft Azure)
- Collaboration tools (Jira Slack, Twilio)
- Build tools (Maven and UBX)
- testing tools (Oxygen, Unmock, Blackfire.io),
- Security tools (Wallarm Snyk SecretHub Cypress)
- Deployment tools (DeployHub Helm OpenShift
- Monitoring tools (Datadog and Honeycomb).
- Code analysis tools (Codecov and CodeScene)
- Languages and frameworks: (Android Flutter Hugo Node.js Rust)
- Many more.
Current connections total 150. Click here for a complete list.
Packages of Reusable Configuration
CircleCI has developed an extensive library of Orbs - or Reusable Configuration Packages created by its partners or members of its community that you can reuse across projects quickly and efficiently.
Already existing Orbs will make creating pipelines much faster. At the same time, you can write your own and use multiple Orbs across projects simultaneously.
Find answers quickly with CircleCI. With its growing popularity comes an array of tutorials and guides created specifically for it; taking full advantage of all these materials to locate answers (or ask other developers) quickly, CircleCI offers quick solutions.
It has excellent documentation available, which provides quick solutions if any issue remains. Furthermore, submit support requests should an issue not be resolved within 12-24 hours; typically, support reps will respond shortly after that.
Main Weaknesses
CircleCI requires knowledge of YAML to build its workflows. At the same time, many other tools provide visual interfaces that make managing workflows simpler.
Predictable Prices As your project expands, so do expenses; per-minute and per-seat models make it challenging to estimate how much money will be spent each month.
Codeship Is A Cloud-Based Ci With Rapid Builds
CodeShip by CloudBees is an AWS-based SaaS offering for running continuous integration/continuous delivery (CI/CD).
CodeShip's parallel pipelines and concurrent builds enable deployment in multiple instances daily - you can quickly scale cloud resources such as CPU memory utilization.
Pricing Models. CodeShip offers two versions, Basic and Pro. Basic provides pre configurations of dependencies with a web interface for deployment management; it does not support Docker, though there are packages from $49 monthly up to $399 that provide increasing levels of CI/CD Solutions parallelism.
Pro, however, supports Docker fully, offering flexible configuration of instances up to 20x parallelization depending on the package selected; with flexible packages starting from $49.49 monthly until $399, you have numerous packages ranging in parallelization capacity to choose from and flexible parallelism up to 20x parallelization potential per package offered versus Basic packages available under Basic version 2. Pricing models
Free plans are also available, though their scope is restricted to one build per month and 100 builds annually with the parallel testing pipeline.
Nonprofit and educational projects receive 50% discounts. Finally, open-source projects remain free.
Selling Points
- Centralized management of teams. CodeShip allows you to create teams easily, assign permissions to members of your team and organizations, and select roles such as Owner, Manager, PM, and Contributor for use with this application.
- CodeShip's Parallel Continuous Integration option enables you to run tests simultaneously.
- Workflow Simplified CodeShip's intuitive UI streamlines workflow, simplifying file configuration and management for easy storage and management. G2 Crowd reviewers have consistently noted how CodeShip makes starting up Git or Bitbucket fast and effortless; compared to these services, they found everything more accessible, including deployment processes being much less cumbersome in CodeShip.
- CodeShip makes code delivery quick and straightforward with one simple button click across multiple environments.
- Reliability CodeShip gives us peace of mind by helping to ensure we're prepared for anything life throws our way.
Main Weaknesses
Documentation Is Deficient Reviews have highlighted CodeShip's documentation as lacking compared to Jenkins. Improvement is recommended here.
Although CodeShip offers limited native integrations compared with similar tools (VictorOps, Opsgenie, SourceClear Snyk for security checks, Raygun for tracking deployments error logs, etc...), they still cover everything needed to run your CI/CD processes successfully.
Want More Information About Our Services? Talk to Our Consultants!
Final suggestions on selecting a CI/CD Tool
Be mindful of your team's needs when selecting continuous integration software. Your team must quickly master any tool chosen to start developing their product quickly.
When narrowing down CI software choices based on expertise or programming tools already known to them.
Consider what features you require of any tool; Jenkins might make sense as a Jenkins CI/CD continuous-integration solution but is less suitable if your focus shifts towards continuous development (CD).
A tool designed specifically to assist delivery and testing, such as Spinnaker, may offer better value - though neither one excels at integration. Each tool excels at one function, so before selecting any solution, it is essential that you first determine your primary business objective and then decide what features will help meet it.
