Continuous Integration, Delivery, or Deployment: Which One Will Save You the Most Time and Money?

Maximizing Efficiency: CI, CD, or Deployment Comparison
Abhishek Founder & CFO cisin.com
In the world of custom software development, our currency is not just in code, but in the commitment to craft solutions that transcend expectations. We believe that financial success is not measured solely in profits, but in the value we bring to our clients through innovation, reliability, and a relentless pursuit of excellence.


Contact us anytime to know moreAbhishek P., Founder & CFO CISIN

 

A Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment pipe aggregates incremental changes made by developers into artifacts for automated tests to run.

Early defect identification, increased CI/CD Engineer productivity and reduced release cycles are the goals.

This process starkly contrasts traditional software development methods--consolidating several minor updates into one significant release and testing thoroughly before finally deploying.

By contrast, continuous integration/continuous delivery (CI/CD) supports agile development practices of minor iterative releases aimed at quickly providing value while creating feedback loops which help developers improve.


What Are The Differences Between Continuous Integration, Delivery And Deployment (Continuous)?

What Are The Differences Between Continuous Integration, Delivery And Deployment (Continuous)?

 


Continuous Integration

Traditional software development processes involve multiple developers creating code independently before consolidating it at the end of a release, leading to numerous bugs and issues that would only be fixed after a prolonged testing period.

The software release was postponed until all issues had been addressed - which negatively impacted its quality. In contrast, teams only released updates once or twice annually.

Continuous Integration was invented to assist Agile Development Processes and address this problem. Through Continuous Integration (CI), any code changes made by developers are instantly integrated into the main branch of a project by way of automated tests designed to catch any quality problems - giving developers immediate feedback regarding any quality concerns and giving them time to address any immediate fixes needed immediately.

Developers frequently commit directly to main or short-lived branches until merged back with changes made on the master. A feature is only considered completed once the code has been fully integrated by merging it all with changes made elsewhere within that main branch and not before that happens merged again.

A Continuous Integration system relies on its build server for integrating new code, testing it with automated tools, merging that code onto its main branch, and producing "build artifacts", or new version software required for the Deployment of software.

Continuous Integration enhances software development qualitatively and speedily, as evidenced by organizations regularly releasing new versions, enabling teams to design features of more excellent value to users.


Continuous Delivery

At one time, software deployment was an intricate, risky, and expensive undertaking. An operation team would typically implement new versions into production after testing was finished - this may take several hours or days depending on its size; manual steps must be completed meticulously with detailed checklists to implement.

Many deployments failed, needing urgent help or developer workarounds being provided immediately.

Traditional approaches have many flaws: they're costly, risky and stressful for teams and organizations, leading to downtime, bugs and stress for everyone involved.

CDel, or Continuous Delivery (CD), seeks to automate these processes to solve this problem; through CD, teams can package software packages easily for release into production environments at one touch with no special effort required from either end. CD enables immediate Deployment of any changes made on software projects straightaway without special effort from one side or another.

After the CI system has combined changes and created a build for testing environment deployment, CD will then package up that version and push it out automatically into production environments after conducting an automatic behavior assessment - there may still be manual approval steps as necessary - regardless of any manual interventions on behalf of CD to push new version into a production environment.

Automating all aspects of software development - building, testing, establishing an environment and Deployment - is crucial to creating Continuous Delivery pipelines (CD).

Artifacts must be stored within an artifact repository, while an environment creation/updating mechanism should also exist. Having such pipelines allows teams to create agile processes while quickly providing customers with value.


Continuous Deployment

CDep goes beyond continuous delivery in that all changes that pass through its pipeline are tested automatically for quality before Deployment into production.

Continuous Deployment eliminates release dates, allows customers to provide quicker feedback loops, and decreases team stress; developers can focus on writing software without worrying about seeing it deployed moments after it was created.

Implementing continuous Deployment can be difficult and complex, as it requires complete automation at every point in the process and robust automated test suites for quality assurance.

Furthermore, continuous-everything cultures need to exist, which enable rapid detection of production problems and timely responses when issues arise.


What Is The Relationship Between CI/CD and DevOps?

What Is The Relationship Between CI/CD and DevOps?

 

DevOps fosters collaboration and communication between development (Dev) and operation teams (Ops). DevOps encourages cooperation between DevOps teams.

Changes often have to occur across various aspects of development, such as job roles, tools or best practices for any successful transition of Dev projects to Ops teams.

DevOps typically includes several components.

  1. Automation, maintenance and Deployment of programmable infrastructure and iterative software design are critical to business.
  2. To increase trust among various disparate parties within teams, we should form cross-functional teams with diverse previous experiences to increase trust between them - while aligning technology to business requirements are all required components of success.

DevOps provides teams with tools that support continuous integration/continuous deployment (CI/CD). CI/CD allows them to streamline development processes while quickly validating and releasing applications to users, streamlining operations.

How it works:

  1. Tools designed to facilitate continuous Integration can assist with initiating processes and ensure developers can test and build code without resorting to manual work.
  2. These tools facilitate production testing, configuration management and release management processes.
  3. Tools designed to facilitate continuous Deployment can run tests automatically while handling configuration, provisioning monitoring, rollbacks and roll forwards as part of their duties.

Want More Information About Our Services? Talk to Our Consultants!


What Are The Stages Of A Pipeline for CI/CD?

What Are The Stages Of A Pipeline for CI/CD?

 

The Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment Pipeline facilitates continuous delivery, Integration and Deployment through four stages: source code, source build, and test deployment.


The Source

Developers begin with source code creation as part of the Continuous Integration and Continuous Deployment (CI/CD) process.

Here, they interpret requirements into algorithms, behaviors and features using tools that vary according to variables such as project language and type - there being no single source-creation pipeline in use here.

Include these components of your source code generation pipeline:

  1. Your choice may include Java or.NET programming language as the programming base language;
  2. Your IDE should support that particular programming language as well. Tools available include vulnerability scanners and essential error detection utilities like Git.

Build

At its heart lies pulling source code out of a repository and linking with libraries, dependencies and modules - before building executable files (.exe).

Tools used for execution log generation often indicate errors as they arise and notify developers if these should be addressed immediately or investigated further.

Build tools can vary significantly across programming languages; depending on a situation or scenario, one may require separate IDE and build tools, while in others, an integrated approach may suffice for both source code editing and build phase processes.

Once built, additional tools may also be utilized during the build phase to transform an executable file into packaged or deployable environments such as Virtual Machines (VM) and Docker containers for execution environments.


Tests

Code is subjected to static testing during development before entering CI/CD's second phase for dynamic testing.

  1. Unit or functional testing - which ensures new features work as anticipated - as well as regression testing, can help ensure any alterations do not break features that were working previously.
  2. Test for regression -Integration, user acceptance and regression testing are also performed on builds during production, so any errors that surface during testing are related to developers for analysis and correction.

Automated testing helps decrease human errors while increasing productivity.


Deploy

An application that has passed the testing stage can now be deployed via conventional deployment methods or automation services such as Jenkins.

  1. Continuous Delivery -- The build is then sent for human staff approval before being released for Deployment, such as when new versions of products are automatically deployed to test environments; their transition into production environments depends upon manual approvals or merge requests.
  2. Continuous Deployment - the pipeline automates Deployment to staging and production environments once builds have passed all tests; no manual approvals are necessary.

At its core, Deployment requires creating and moving an environment from its creation point to an eventual target, such as a server.

These steps may be automated using scripts and workflows within automation tools for seamless implementation; moreover, many deployments integrate ticketing or error reporting tools to detect unexpected errors after release and notify developers accordingly.


Benefits in CI/CD Pipelines

Benefits in CI/CD Pipelines

 

Automation and expedited updates to application updates are crucial when adopting continuous CI/CD Software Development integration/continuous delivery (CI/CD); teams commonly encounter several challenges:

  1. Manual Steps in the Release Process--Many continuous Integration and delivery processes still use manual deployment and testing steps, leading to delays in production and schedule disruptions. Furthermore, this approach could cause code merging conflicts that extend patch delivery timelines for customers waiting longer before receiving patches and updates from your business.
  2. Risk of Downtime --Manual infrastructure management can create headaches for DevOps because it increases the chances of downtime. Unexpected traffic surges may force applications offline and require manual interventions to restore them online.
  3. Resource wastage- apps deployed on servers inefficiently force organizations to spend more on capacity than necessary and utilize hardware efficiently as applications expand or contract as applications run either remotely in the cloud or locally on-premise. This challenges organizations' resource utilization.

Kubernetes offers solutions to these three problems by shortening the time and effort needed for app development, increasing hardware utilization and automating processes while decreasing customer interruptions.

Kubernetes can:

  1. Cluster Management -- Kubernetes provides all of the best practices from all clustering solutions in an impartial fashion, including schedulers, resource managers and plugin mechanisms such as storage networking secrets. Kubernetes makes writing distributed applications much simpler than legacy clustering systems, as its environment provides standard mechanisms rather than proprietary ones that inhibit productivity.
  2. Orchestrate deployment and provisioning by streamlining activities related to provisioning activities and simplifying Deployment. Kubernetes is a container orchestration system which manages software/hardware resource configuration, scaling, health monitoring and deployment tasks; fully customizable versions may even meet unique customer specifications.
  3. Declarative constructs--coding the desired final state in human-readable code to define how things should look--can reduce downtime, boost production, facilitate disaster recovery and manage scaling more effectively.

Cloud CI/CD

Cloud CI/CD

 

Cloud services provide developers with an effective means of Continuous Integration (CI) and Continuous Delivery/Deployment of software development projects, offering greater scalability and agility to quickly develop, test, and deploy applications more rapidly and efficiently than traditional methods can do alone.

Cloud service providers like AWS Azure Google Cloud offer tools and services that facilitate continuous integration/Deployment (CI/CD).

Examples are:

  1. Source Control in the Cloud: Many providers of source control software like GitHub, GitLab, and Bitbucket offer cloud-based source control services that allow businesses to store and manage code securely online. These platforms also facilitate easy collaboration on projects among team members.
  2. Build and Test Automation: Services such as AWS CodeBuild, Azure DevOps and Google Cloud Build are used to automate building and testing code.
  3. Containerization, Orchestration, & Migration: Services such as Amazon Web Services Elastic Container Service (ECS), Azure Container Instances and Google Kubernetes Engine can help containerize applications into containers for easy management and Deployment in the cloud.
  4. Deployment Automation: Services such as AWS CodeDeploy, Azure DevOps and Google Cloud Deployment Manager can automate code deployment into different environments, including production, development and staging environments.
  5. Monitoring: Cloud providers offer various monitoring and logging services, such as AWS CloudWatch and Azure Monitor; Google Stackdriver is also an option.

These services enable developers to easily configure, manage and set up a Continuous Integration and Continuous Deployment Pipeline in the Cloud, speeding the delivery of new features to clients while helping identify issues early and correcting them more rapidly during development cycles.

Faddom offers this comprehensive guide on cloud migration to help shed more light.


CD/CI Tools

CD/CI Tools

 

This is a short review of some popular CI/CD software.


Continuous Integration Tools

Popular Continuous Integration Tools include Codefresh, Bitbucket Pipelines, Jenkins CircleCI Bamboo and GitLab CI.

Codefresh: Codefresh is an integrated GitOps Continuous Integration toolset tailored specifically towards Kubernetes, modern applications and other cloud-based systems.

At its heart lies Argo Workflows and events - core features that combine with enterprise features like an enterprise-grade security runtime environment for seamless suitability of enterprise features such as auditability.

Bitbucket Pipelines: This Continuous Integration tool integrates directly with Bitbucket's cloud-based Source Control system for easy development pipeline management and Deployment via CD tools.

Bitbucket pipelines allow developers to define pipelines and start builds.

Jenkins: Jenkins is an open-source automation tool featuring plugins for developing, deploying, and delivering software.

The server allows developers to divide tasks among machines, perform tests across computers, deploy code across machines simultaneously, and even manage Continuous Integration pipelines with its Pipeline plugins.

CircleCI: CircleCI is designed to integrate seamlessly with various container environments, delivery mechanisms, and version control systems like Github.

Among its capabilities lies resource classes caching Docker layers pipelines running simultaneously within CircleCI on-premise or cloud platforms.

Bamboo: Bamboo is a continuous integration automation server which builds, tests, integrates, documents and automates source code so apps are ready for Deployment.

Offering user-friendly functionality such as automatic merging support for deployment support and integrated support features CI/CD features that include automated merging support can prepare apps for release with minimum hassle and the desired level of automation.

GitLab CI: GitLab CI is an open-source continuous integration (CI) tool. You can use it to quickly set up and install projects using GitLab API, build, test, and deploy projects quickly, and identify areas for improvement while securely protecting project data using confidential issues.


Continuous Deployment and Delivery Tools

Codefresh, ArgoCD, GoCD and AWS CodePipeline are popular CD tools.

GitOps-powered software delivery platform powered by Argo, supports advanced releases such as canary, experimental, and blue-green deployments.

comprehensive dashboards give visibility between code and cloud while also connecting you with the tools you prefer - providing insight on deployments while offering enterprise security support.

Argo CD: a Kubernetes native CD tool optimized for GitOps, stores configuration in a Git repository that automatically applies it across Kubernetes Clusters - making Integration seamless into existing workflows.

Argo CD detects configuration drift while monitoring application health and quickly rolls back unwanted configuration changes - perfect for rolling back unwanted changes with blue/green or canary deployment strategies.

GoCD: GoCD is an open-source CD tool that automates the build and release process from code check-in through Deployment via its plugin ecosystem of Git (Subversion), Mercurial, TFS VCS VCL VMS Perforce integrations.

GoCD can also be installed locally onsite.

AWS CodePipeline: A cloud service geared toward continuous software change management and release automation, AWS CodePipeline helps model, visualize and automate continuous software changes and release steps with features like release automation and providing a consistent process for software release and pipeline details to display.

Azure Pipelines: Azure Pipelines is a cloud service designed to build, test, and ship code using a combination of continuous integration/delivery mechanisms.

It supports various languages, including Python, Java Script and Go, and most applications, including Node.js and C++.

Spinnaker: An open-source CD platform explicitly designed for multi-cloud environments. Integrating many cloud service providers, this system manages pipelines.

Furthermore, an automated release builder and JSON format pipeline storage/reuse are provided to ensure seamless deployments with Kubernetes support.

GitHub Actions: the world-famed Continuous Integration/Continuous Delivery software tool offered by GitHub is widely renowned.

Teams are using it to automate workflows within their repositories. GitHub Actions allows developers to quickly build custom workflows using simple YAML syntax while accessing an online marketplace of user-contributed actions for additional flexibility.

Harness.io: Harness.io is an easy and user-friendly CI/CD platform designed for ease of use, featuring a visual user interface for building deployment pipelines and automating daily CI/CD tasks like rollbacks and canaries.

Furthermore, Harness automatically verifies all deployments in real time to identify and address potential issues before end users become affected.

Read More: How Does CI/CD Accelerate Software Development?


CI/CD Security Risks

CI/CD Security Risks

 


Attacking Supply Chains:

Supply chain attacks are cyber-attacks which aim to identify weak spots within an organization's supply chain network - comprising individuals, organizations, technologies, activities and resources involved with creating or selling software products or services.

Software applications of today rely heavily on dependencies for their core functionality, with entire ecosystems depending on continuous integration/continuous deployment (CI/CD) to publish source code and binary files to public repositories - something hackers exploit by circumventing security checks to attack the supply chain directly, infiltrating many websites/apps simultaneously.


Unsecure System Configuration:

A continuous integration and deployment (CI/CD) system comprises various systems from various vendors; security teams should prioritize health and resilience to optimize CI/CD.

As with any system that processes or stores data, CI/CD environments feature security configurations at application, infrastructure and network levels - impacting its security posture and vulnerability; attackers constantly look out for any weaknesses within these configurations which might allow access.


Code Insecurity:

Open-source integrations have grown increasingly prevalent due to the demand for faster software delivery. Yet, some teams may integrate third-party components without first scanning for vulnerabilities, thus potentially opening the CI/CD pipeline up to security risks without proper adherence to security standards by developers; attack surfaces may increase as vulnerabilities such as buffer overflows or errors in error handling lead to user input problems that necessitate further analysis and fixing.


The Exposure of Secrets:

Automation is at the core of DevOps environments. Automation makes software release more seamless by automating configuration and orchestration tools with continuous integration/continuous delivery capabilities (CI/CD software), but these require accessing sensitive resources like code repositories or databases containing sensitive resources (API tokens/passwords are typically required), making storage, sending or auditing of secrets increasingly challenging as more secrets accumulate in any given DevOps environment.

Secrets can also be used to authenticate tools. Sometimes, sensitive information must be shared during Deployment and build processes so deployed resources have access.

It is especially critical when using auto-scaling tools such as Kubernetes for microservice Deployment.


DevSecOps, CI/CD and DevSecOps

DevSecOps, CI/CD and DevSecOps

 

DevSecOps refers to both organizational culture and philosophy, which incorporates security within DevOps development processes while at the same time offering continuous delivery CI/CD Solutions capabilities.

It describes an SDLC incorporating security within iteration cycles for software development projects.

Security was previously treated as an optional component of DevOps; information security measures were applied towards the end of software development lifecycles (SDLC), making addressing security issues very frustrating and time-consuming.

Now, there is DevSecOps, which integrates software developers throughout SDLC development phases as security is considered from its conception to completion.

DevOps typically involves various phases, such as developing, testing and releasing software applications or services.

DevSecOps takes additional security precautions at every phase of the DevOps process: building, testing and releasing.

  1. Planning: In the planning stage, you will create a comprehensive strategy outlining when, where and how a security evaluation and test scenarios will occur.
  2. Coding: Employ linting and Git Controls to Safeguard API Keys and Passwords.
  3. Building: Utilize static application testing tools (SASTs) before Deployment into production as they track bugs within code that has yet to be deployed into production - these specialized tools for particular programming languages provide added assurances against defects that could come about through Deployment into production.
  4. Dynamic Application Security Testing tools (DAST) should be utilized during application testing to detect errors related to user authentication, SQL injection and API endpoints.
  5. Release: Implement security analysis tools to scan for vulnerabilities and conduct penetration tests before deploying your app. These should be employed immediately before their deployment.
  6. Deployment: Once all tests have been successfully passed, a secure build should be put into production for Deployment. Runtime checks should take place to identify vulnerabilities or security threats that still need to be discovered.

Best Practices for CI/CD

Best Practices for CI/CD

 

Below are a few best practices to effectively implement Continuous Integration/Continuous Delivery (CI/CD).


Building Only Once:

Instead, create the source code once for packaging or bundling software. The build step should only take place once to package or bundle software properly and safely for testing in a clean area - eliminating human error while decreasing chances of incorrect or overlooked artifacts being included in software builds.

All artifacts uploaded must also be versioned to Git to guarantee availability at every point during development cycles.


Prioritize Automation Efforts:

Organizations often find it challenging to determine which processes should be automated first when automating processes like code compilation from scratch is often an obvious candidate for automation first.

Automating smoke tests would reduce developer workload significantly, as would automating unit tests beforehand. This strategy typically reduces overhead significantly as well.

Functional testing should always come before user interface testing when automating since functional tests don't require as frequent updates to their automation scripts as user interface tests, which must be updated more often.

Care should be taken in prioritizing automation based on its impact and impact assessment, then prioritization by dependencies or impacts of automation script updates.


Release of Software:

Ongoing Testing and Commercial Release Only When software has undergone rigorous testing and is approved, it may only be released commercially.

Therefore, it's advisable to include a deployment step where new versions can be introduced into pre-production environments or the actual production environments alongside their current counterpart.

Release strategies provide an efficient method for deploying software with minimum risk in staging and production environments.


Canary Deployment:

Introduce the new version to some users for testing, then expand, if successful, to more people. If any tests fail, switch to the previous version before trying again with fresh data.

  1. Blue/Green Deployment: To simultaneously test out new and current versions in two identical environments. At first, only the current one runs live while traffic from the existing version is routed over to an environment that contains the new version for testing purposes; once traffic shifts from it onto an environment housing the new version for real-world usage testing, if anything goes wrong, it is easy and immediate to rollback back.
  2. A/B Test: An A/B test is used to evaluate the usability of an application. Parallel, two or more versions with minor variations are presented to users simultaneously, and teams observe how users react to them compared with each version rolled out across all users once one of them has proven itself successful.
  3. A Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment pipeline is essential to successful software delivery: Investment in fast, reliable and secure Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment processes will give you confidence that builds are of top-notch quality; bypassing them could thwart these efforts; therefore, it should never be practical or minor requests to bypass release procedures should be granted.

Unfortunately, automated testing alone isn't enough: due to builds not automatically being deployed into test and production environments, debugging issues becomes more arduous and reproducing them more difficult.

Understand why your team made its decisions by understanding its motivations. Determine why the request was initially initiated; speak to key stakeholders regarding whether their process seems slow and inflexible; address these concerns by improving performance or processes where applicable.

Avoid disrupting CI/CD processes by responding to stakeholders' needs and conveying their benefits.


Every Release Cleans the Environment:

Before every Deployment, your pre-production environment must be cleaned up. Configuration drift can develop over time as long-running systems experience configuration drift, and tests may no longer return the expected result.

Attempts at keeping static systems functional are expensive and can prolong testing efforts and delays associated with release dates.

Kubernetes makes this task more straightforward by using declarative configuration, like its YAML files, to start and destroy environments as soon as they've been deployed.

Creating new containers before each Deployment ensures consistency while scaling your environment for testing multiple builds simultaneously.

Want More Information About Our Services? Talk to Our Consultants!


Take CI/CD To The Next Level

mission has been to accelerate innovation among teams. Our CI/CD Automotive Argo-powered platform combines open-source software with enterprise runtimes so teams can take full advantage of Argo Workflows and Events.

It provides teams with an end-to-end environment to develop, test, scale and deploy applications quickly and securely.