Is Agile or Waterfall the Optimal Software Development Model? Cost and Impact Analysis Reveals the Answer!

Agile vs Waterfall: Cost & Impact Analysis Results
Abhishek Founder & CFO cisin.com
In the world of custom software development, our currency is not just in code, but in the commitment to craft solutions that transcend expectations. We believe that financial success is not measured solely in profits, but in the value we bring to our clients through innovation, reliability, and a relentless pursuit of excellence.


Contact us anytime to know moreAbhishek P., Founder & CFO CISIN

 

Although each technique has distinctive traits of its own, organizing project management is the overarching objective.

Teams can build high-quality software rapidly and affordably because of this.


What Is The Sdlc Model? How Can It Improve The Quality And Efficiency Of Your Process?

What Is The Sdlc Model? How Can It Improve The Quality And Efficiency Of Your Process?

 

The software development lifecycle model is used in project management to define different phases of software development.

This strategy details the creation, upkeep, and replacement of particular software. The SDLC paradigm has the power to succeed or fail with your project. When selecting an SDLC model, it is important to take into account the stakeholders' deadlines, financial limits, and standards for quality.

The lifecycle is a method for improving software quality and the overall development process. Today, there are more than 50 models accessible for software development.

Despite the number of models available, not every model is ideal. According to the demands of a project and team, each model offers advantages and disadvantages of its own. We have 20 years of experience in the field and have examined the eight most common models during software development with a focus on their fundamental characteristics.

This will enable you to succeed today and in the future. It's crucial to comprehend the fundamentals of software development. Let's examine each SDLC model as well as select which one we should employ to ensure the success of our project.


What Are The Basic Stages Of Sdlc?

What Are The Basic Stages Of Sdlc?

 


Stage 1 - Planning And Analysis

Each software development cycle starts with an analysis in which process stakeholders talk about what the finished product should have.

The system requirements are precisely defined at this point. Additionally, it's critical to make sure that everyone working on the project is aware of what each criterion implies and how it may be met.


Stage 2: Creating Project Architecture

The second phase is often when developers create the architecture. Customers and all other stakeholders have the opportunity to discuss any potential technical problems at this point.


Stage 3 - Development And Programming

The process then advances to real development when the requirements have been approved. Here, programmers start writing source code while taking into consideration the specifications that were previously set.

The user interfaces, as well as server-side logic, are created by front-end programmers. The software environment is created by system administrators for mobile applications.


Stage 4 - Code Testing

During the testing stage, debugging happens. All programming errors found during development are noted and sent back to the developers for correction by mobile app development services.


Stage 5 - Deployment

Corrections are necessary after the programme has been evaluated and found to be free of serious defects. Repeating this procedure ensures that all significant issues are corrected.

The tech support group will be accessible upon the publication of the updated version of the programme. This division provides assistance during exploitation as well as user feedback and advice. To make sure that the software is safe and current, this phase comprises updating a few specific components.

Read More: What Is Software Product Development Companies 2023?


What Are The Best Sdlc Models To Use For Your Software Development Projects?

What Are The Best Sdlc Models To Use For Your Software Development Projects?

 

An overview of the most widely used SDLC methods may help you choose which one is right for your project's software development.


Waterfall Model

A cascading waterfall is a waterfall. The first approach to software development is this one. It follows a linear flow in order.

When a stage is finished, work can begin on the following stage.

The biggest disadvantage of the waterfall is its rigidity. The Waterfall model is easy to administer and comprehend.

If the project is not finished on time, it might be postponed. Once a phase is complete, there is usually little room for changes and reviews. Any problems cannot be resolved after the product is under maintenance.

This is why ongoing or lengthy projects don't suit the strategy effectively.

The waterfall method of software development is favored by many. The waterfall model contains consecutive phases (requirements design, implementation validation maintenance), each of which focuses on a distinct objective.

It is a linear, inflexible structure. Before the next step may start, the previous phase must be finished. Rarely can you go back and adjust the project's course.

Advantages: The waterfall development approach is simple to grasp and keep up with because of the linear structure.

The waterfall development process works best for projects with well-defined criteria and goals. The waterfall development process works well with teams that shift frequently, have inexperienced project managers, and our project teams.

Cons: Waterfall development has a reputation for being expensive and slow because of the rigid structure, stringent regulations, and slow rate of advancement.

This may prompt users of the waterfall method to consider alternative software development techniques.


Agile Software Development

Technology for agile software development has been in existence for more than ten years. Numerous IT companies utilize it.

Agile modeling is so appreciated by some businesses that they now use it for non-technical projects.

Agile helps teams identify and address minor problems during software development. It is important to address minor issues before they become more serious.

Agile allows for continuous releases, with small incremental changes to each release. Each iteration has software testing. In the development process, business stakeholders are encouraged to participate and provide feedback.

Scrum is an Agile framework that is very popular. Scrum is used to develop software products and services. It requires careful attention to continuous delivery to ensure that the development team does not become overwhelmed by Microsoft application development services.

The Kanban methodology, like some other Agile frameworks, aims to reduce conflict and increase team productivity.

Task coordination within project teams is accomplished using the Kanban method, task boards, as well as other Agile project management technologies. It is feasible to visually describe work at various phases of the process. A certain stage of the work process is represented by each column.

This board shows how Kanban can be used to manage work at both an organizational and personal level. When should you utilize Agile software development methods is a frequent query. Any project can use these models. The advantages for businesses using them, however, include the following:

  1. Lower cost.
  2. Rapid releases.
  3. The end result is more pleasing for clients.

    This is possible because clients are involved in the development process and help to improve it.

  4. Open lines of communication between customers and teams;
  5. Team members gain an advantage over rivals by spotting flaws early and fixing them as they go along instead of waiting until the very end.
  6. Quicker modifications during the development process are encouraged by routinely comparing the product to anticipated results.
  7. Project management transparency.

    To achieve this transparency, regular interactions with clients, as well as system administrators, are essential.

    This makes it possible for everyone to access project data and follow its development.

  8. For rapid improvement, it is important to get regular feedback.

To lower risk when introducing new functionality, teams utilize agile development (such as bugs, cost overruns as well as changing requirements).

Teams must develop the software using all agile methodologies in short, functionally-rich increments. Various agile development methodologies exist, including scrum, crystal, extreme programming (XP), or feature-driven development (FDD).

Advantages: The ability to deliver software in brief iterations is one of the key advantages of agile software development.

Iterative releases increase efficiency and allow teams to identify and fix bugs early. Additionally, this harmonizes expectations. Software benefits can also be experienced by users more quickly with frequent incremental changes.

Cons: Real-time communication is essential to agile development methodologies. New users frequently lack the necessary documentation to stay current with the updates.

These demand a significant time investment from users and thus are labor-intensive because developers must finish each item in order to win user approval.

Rapid application creation is comparable to agile development methodologies (see below), although a wide range of enterprises may find them ineffective.

It may be challenging for managers, programmers, and other companies accustomed to the waterfall technique to transition to an agile SDLC. For them, a hybrid strategy is frequently a wise decision.

Get a Free Estimation or Talk to Our Business Manager!


Lean Model

Each and every Lean transformation should enhance the organization's general well-being. Toyota reduced waste and inefficiency in its production area by implementing Lean production ideas and techniques.

The seven Lean principles are as follows:

  1. Get rid of waste (any non-value-added component in any process).
  2. Stress ongoing education.
  3. Choose as late as you can.
  4. Deliver as soon as you can.
  5. Encourage the team.
  6. Build integrity.
  7. See the entire picture.

Lean aims to reduce waste while maximizing customer value. The term "lean approach" refers to the process of maximizing people, energy, as well as resources within your business to generate value for consumers.

Continuous improvement, as well as respect for others, are key to learning. Every employee has been expected to deliver value and improve services while exerting less effort.

This entails streamlining all operational and auxiliary procedures that support essential programmes and services. Lean has adopted stream maps as a way to reduce waste from duplicate efforts as well as inefficient processes. Companies can use lean value stream mapping to pinpoint the areas where value flows between various activities and make educated decisions regarding what will satisfy customers the most.


The Iterative And Incremental Method

Repetition is the foundation of iterative models. Without knowing comprehensive requirements, project teams remain free to implement a collection of known requirements.

After that, Evaluation and testing happen. There are more prerequisites found. A new version is created during each phase or iteration. It will be necessary to rinse and retest the finished product until it is ready.

The benefit of iterative models is that you can start with a usable product. Making modifications is made simpler as a result. But constant repetitions might quickly deplete your resources.


Prototyping

A system prototype is a short rendition created for customer testing. The possibility that the finished product will be rapidly approved is increased when the client participates in the design process.

Prototyping can be helpful when the client or the developer is uncertain about a design's viable product requirements, algorithms, and business rules.


Spiral Method

One of the most adaptable SDLC techniques is the spiral model. It is based on the repetitions of the iterative model.

Four phases of the project can indeed be identified:

  1. Planning
  2. Risk analysis
  3. Engineering
  4. Evaluation

For improvement, these steps are repeated in a "spiral." Large-scale projects are the main application for spiral models.

As a result, product development teams can incorporate consumer feedback early on and produce highly customized goods. Risk management is also handled by this SDLC approach. After a thorough examination of the potential risks as well as the development of a strategy to mitigate or eliminate them, each iteration starts.

The Spiral Model can be utilized by employing risk assessment professionals. The cycle depends on these four tasks: Planning, Risk analysis, prototype development, and testing.

Customer input is crucial when reviewing or investigating prior tasks. This cycle keeps going longer and longer as your project progresses. Each cycle involves consumer input. Customers can participate in the Evaluation process to investigate certain elements and still voice their suggestions for improvements.

Use Cases

  1. Complex projects that combine both complexity and size.
  2. New product or service introductions, as well as research and development initiatives.

Read More: How Much Time do you Take to Build a Custom Software Product?


DevOps Model

The SDLC sector has recently adopted the DevOps methodology. Agile and Lean methodologies are two trends that gave birth to DevOps.

Dedicated Teams working on operations also used these models. The cooperation between operations and development staff during the SDLC process is emphasized in this article.

In the DevOps paradigm, software developers and operations personnel occasionally work as a single team. Faster innovation and higher-quality software products are made possible as a result.

Products are often, albeit incrementally, updated. Discipline, constant feedback, process improvement, as well as continuous feedback are characterized by these.

DevOps is more than just a development technique. A collection of procedures supporting corporate culture is also a part of it.

Quality assurance, development, or operations are only a few of the departments engaged in the development lifecycle. DevOps deployment focuses on organizational change to increase communication across these departments.

Advantages: DevOps focuses on reducing lead times between fixes, accelerating time to market, lowering failure rates for new releases, and minimizing downtime while maximizing reliability.

Continuous deployment is something that DevOps organizations want to automate in order to make sure everything goes smoothly and dependably. DevOps aids businesses in accelerating time to market, enhancing customer satisfaction, quality of products, and worker effectiveness.

Cons: DevOps has its advantages, but there are some drawbacks.

  1. Some customers do not want to receive continuous updates on their systems.
  2. Before a project requirements can progress to the operations phase, rules in several industries need rigorous testing.
  3. Undiscovered issues may sneak into production if different departments work in different environments.
  4. Certain quality attributes are best when human interaction is required.

    This slows down delivery.


Rapid Application Development

Rapid application development (RAD), a streamlined method for creating systems, is inexpensive and results in high-caliber solutions.

In a fast-paced, constantly-changing industry, RAD enables developers to respond quickly to shifting requirements, according to the research. This is what makes investing in Technologies such a cheap proposition.

The four stages of rapid application development are requirements Planning, user design, construction, and cutover.

As long as the user is pleased that the product meets all needs, the customer design phase or building phase will continue.

Advantages: Rapid app development services are best for projects that have a clear company goal and carefully defined users but are not too complex computationally.

Time-sensitive small- through medium-sized projects benefit the most from RAD.

Cons: In a short development time frame, approval must be given after each phase. These requirements will not be met by organizations that want to receive RAD.


What Software Development Method Should I Use For My Project?

What Software Development Method Should I Use For My Project?

 

These are the top four techniques used in software development. Each one works well enough in different circumstances and has strengths and flaws of its own.

To find the optimal mix for both you and your project, think about blending components from each strategy. As a result, you will be able to develop a hybrid technique that will help you reach production swiftly and securely.

The SDLC (Software/System Development Life Cycle) paradigm that uses Agile is the most popular. Agile is a collection of frameworks that provide rapid and effective answers based on contemporary business circumstances.

Its main focus is customer feedback and communication with stakeholders. Agile is multifunctional, but it has its flaws.

This model might not be right for everyone. The best model for your software development process is one that suits you best, considering the different industries and their requirements.


How Can You Develop Software In The Best Way?

How Can You Develop Software In The Best Way?

 

There isn't any correct response. Agile has drawbacks despite the fact that it can be versatile. There are simply too many industries with various development times, and it doesn't function well for all customers.

The world may appear to be more complicated than it truly is.

SDLC evolution has led to the development of many models. This illustrates the variety of needs and requirements for various enterprises.

It's not about coming up with the ideal model but rather about figuring out what suits your company culture the most.

Get a Free Estimation or Talk to Our Business Manager!


Summary

We've covered seven common models of custom software development company.

We will remind you about their benefits. For smaller projects with clear needs that can be quickly changed, a waterfall is an excellent option. It is a methodical strategy.

The stages are simple to follow and comprehend.

For small and medium-sized projects that need quick adjustments, Agile and Lean approaches are excellent. The customer is involved at every stage.

A project can indeed be started right away with little preparation. To save time and money, each iteration can indeed be negotiated between the client, the development team, and the company.

For large projects, the Iterative or Incremental methods work well together. The software was first developed early. This allows customers to evaluate the software and provide feedback. Prototyping models allow you to visualize certain components of the software.

As a result, there are fewer misunderstandings between the client, this same developer team, as well as the client.

The Prototyping and Waterfall models are both included in the Spiral model. Projects that require complexity and scope work best using a spiral. Risk management, as well as stage-by-stage advancements, are two of its benefits.

The DevOps model is still quite young. This makes it possible to develop software continuously, solve issues more quickly, and have happier, more effective workers.

Depending on the project, CISIN employs a range of SDLC alternatives. The ideal method for developing software is it is important to use flexible models such as Agile-based Scrum, Kanban, and Lean.

Having a group of professionals committed to advancing the project at every iteration is equally crucial. For any project you may have, we can offer the best IT engineers. The best software development approach will be chosen based on the particulars of your project and your preferences.

We are pleased to help you!